5 most underrated baseball players of MLB 2025

Amid all the whiz-bang attention grabbed by stars like Shohei Ohtani and Juan Soto in the high-octane world of Major League Baseball, several players put together a sustained excellence that doesn't receive their due. So, as we move through the 2025 season, let’s take a look at five such underrated players who are providing meaningful production for their teams.
José Ramírez , the perennial underappreciated starA six-time All-Star who has placed in the top 10 of M.V.P. voting seven times, José Ramírez of the Cleveland Guardians somehow still flies under the radar. And in 2024, he came close to becoming the first player in history to reach 40-40-40: 41 stolen bases, 39 home runs, and 39 doubles. He’s reliable day in and day out and provides leadership as well as stability to a team that still isn’t over the top, but he is one of the better players the league nearly always forgets about.
Emerging talents making their mark in Major League BaseballSeveral young players are stepping up and proving their worth in the 2025 season:

• Lawrence Butler , Oakland Athletics: Still just 24, Butler seemed to show what he was all about after the All-Star break in 2024, hitting 17 of his 22 dingers after July and slugging .938 OPS in 66 games. His play was rewarded with a seven-year, $65.5 million extension, an early indication from the team that they believe in his long-term contributions.
  

THUNDER & LIGHTNING!! A 3 BOMB DAY FOR RAW DAWG!#LawrenceButler #Athletics pic.twitter.com/vsVTCgiiHD

— Cayla F1 (@CaylaMonacoF1) August 30, 2024

• Christian Walker , Houston Astros: Walker has power, but he’s known for his defense at first base, with some gold glove hardware and an average of 29 homers per 162 games. Yet, somehow, he’s still one of baseball’s most underrecognized figures, especially after his three-year, $60 million deal with the Astros.
  

• Jarren Duran , Boston Red Sox: Duran did a little bit of everything in 2024 — and for his career — leading Gamecocks in hits (191), doubles (48), triples (14), and runs (111). He was key in Boston but often a sidelight beside bigger names around the league.
  

• Kyle Tucker , Chicago Cubs: Since being dealt by the Astros, Tucker has been a steady force on offense. He outhit Juan Soto in slugging percentage and OPS in 2024 despite appearing in fewer games. That performance level is elite, and he doesn’t always get the credit he deserves.
  

Also Read: MLB Report: Kansas City Royals eye Josh Hammond and Mason Neville in bold 2025 MLB Draft move

Players like these, who truly represent the incredibly deep level of talent in MLB, performers who might not get the same acclaim as the marquee stars, but who are consistent, high-quality performers, just like the guys who were out there. And as the season wears on, their relentless quality might result in them earning the recognition they’ve always worked towards.